The Vigilantes of Montana: 1864 Revisited

Statement of Myth 2

Plummer was a man of most insinuating address and gentlemanly manners under ordinary circumstances, and had the art of ingratiating himself with men and even with ladies and women of all conditions. Wherever he dwelt, victims and mistresses of this wily seducer were to be found. It was only when excited by passion that his savage instincts got the better of him and that he appeared -- in his true colors -- a very demon. In 1856 or 1857, he was elected Marshal of the city of Nevada, and had many enthusiastic friends. He was re-elected and received the nomination of the Democratic party for the Assembly near the close of his term of office; but as he raised a great commotion by his boisterous demeanor, caused by his success they ''threw off on him" and elected another man.

Before the expiration of his official year, he murdered a German named Vedder, with whose wife he had an intrigue. He was one day prosecuting his illicit amours, when Vedder came home, and on hearing his footsteps, he went out and ordered him back. As the unfortunate man continued his approach, he shot him dead. For this offense Plummer was arrested and tried, first in Nevada, where he was convicted and sentenced to ten years in the penitentiary; and second, in Yuba County, on a re-hearing with a change of venue. Here the verdict was confirmed. and he was sent to prison.

After several months' confinement his friends petitioned for his release on the alleged ground that he was consumptive, and he was discharged with a pardon signed by Governor John P. Weller. He then returned to Nevada, and joined again with Hyer R Co. in the "Lafayette Bakery."

To see the truth, press the NEXT button.